Diversity Bad? Not Hardly!
Posted by Mitch Mitchell on Feb 8, 2012
I once read an editorial printed in a local newspaper on the "racism" of diversity. I have to admit that I was stunned by the title, and as I read the article I got angry, then had to take a step back. The overall idea of diversity at its core is that every person gets to have their point of view on something, no matter how abhorrent that stance might seem to someone like myself.
Scott Maxwell via Compfight |
For the record, the point of the article at the time was directed at a case before the Supreme Count involving the University of Michigan and its admission policies as it pertains to attempting to have a diverse student population. The author of the editorial not only disagreed with this policy, which puts him in line with President Bush, but decided to go further in his denouncement of the ideals of diversity across the board.
The term "diversity" is suddenly becoming a word with a negative connotation, ala "liberal", in today's society, and that's not a good thing. Only those with no real clue as to the problems in the real world can really believe diversity is such a bad thing.
What makes it better that every university, every company, every organization, whatever, is overloaded with one group over another? It made me wonder if the author was really racist himself or whether he was "under educated" as opposed to uneducated.
I'm from what would be acknowledged as an official minority group. As someone with a little bit of history on the subject, I can assure folks that there isn't anything close to a level playing field in this country.
With the trials and tribulations I had as it regards my educational background in elementary school, high school, and college, I can honestly say that it prepared me for many things I would run into in the work world. I was able to persevere and advance, but each step up the ladder just reminded me of how much of an oddity I was. In the year 2011 and with at least 300 years of history behind us, being in a position where I still make so many lists of "the 1st" to do whatever is shocking to me.
There is a great aversion by some against Affirmative Action. What's missed is that there is still a great need for the program in many ways.
Companies have had the opportunity to do the right thing on their own, and have traditionally decided they didn't really want to buck the status quo, and therefore have not hired "certain people, while always believing it was in the best interest of the company not to do so.
Am I to believe that out of a company of over 200 employees there wasn't a single minority applicant with the skills and background to be a valuable employee to that company? When it comes to unskilled labor, are we really to believe that there's such a great difference in skills between those who are considered in the majority and those considered in the minority?
The way I see things, those whose feelings are like that particular writer (who I decided I didn't want to promote here) are ready to perpetuate the status quo. One reason I have had people tell me that the reasons they don't have any minority representation in management is that there isn't anyone with the skills needed to be promoted. Many of those companies have no minorities anyway, so the point is moot. Where are disenfranchised people supposed to get any skills or background needed to compete in today's business world if no one is willing to hire them?
College is a good place to start. What about quotas? Colleges have quotas anyway.
There are set asides for students whose parents work at the university; there are set asides for students whose families give money to the university; there are set asides for people who live in a particular area (state universities have only a minimum number of slots for out of state students); there are set asides for veterans; it goes on and on.
I see nothing wrong with the policy at the University of Michigan, because it has students in particular groups competing against others within differing categories for slots at the university. It's not like U of M is taking people who are qualified based only in the order they happen to apply to the university.
Once a degree has been earned, minorities need the opportunities to get into companies just like everyone else. Of course their ideas will come from a different perspective, but ideas are what makes companies great in the first place. Someone had an idea and then either went with it or passed it on to someone else, who put it all in place. If this person had aspirations of moving up the ladder, they'll do what's needed in order to attain the skills needed for consideration.
Al Campanis wasn't necessarily wrong in 1987 when he said minorities didn't have all the necessities to be considered for promotion; of course he was talking about baseball and he delivered his message incorrectly. The same applies to businesses in general. Companies need to offer the opportunity for minorities to attain the necessities so that they can advance. The same goes for colleges across the country.
For its really bad.The same applies to businesses in general. Companies need to offer the opportunity for minorities to attain the necessities so that they can advance.
Catherine, if any company uses the belief that minorities aren’t qualified then I agree. Truthfully, I think there are way more qualified candidates than many companies want to own up to.
I can’t really get it, Mitch. We are living in 21st century, we went to the moon about 50 years ago and some people are still trying to find differences.
I’m with you Carl but I think it will always be like this until the playing field levels out a bit more. Sometimes people need someone else to blame their failures on.
I want to see people united all over the world, or I am sure that we will not gonna make it. I am very much surprised as everywhere people are talking about education, there are so many studies about responsibility, leadership, team building. Why nobody read and more importantly try to understand this?
But what I have observed Mitch, most of the big companies doesn’t give priorities to the minorities. I know what they are thinking, maybe because they thought minorities cannot help with their business.
Divina, I’m not sure anyone wants priorities given, just fairness so that everyone has a shot at better positions.
Mitch this is actually one of my favorite topics of discussion…. well, not in the sense that I love something about it; I simply would love to try and understand it. Unfortunately though, I find that most Americans don’t really like to discuss it much. Do you find this to be the case?
Great read, I really enjoyed your thoughts on this! Thanks for sharing.
Oh yeah Deeone, Americans hate discussing this topic, which is why I work hard at keeping it out here. It’s easier to try to ignore these types of things, but they can’t ever be worked out if people don’t talk about it.
Hi Mitch,
I would like to excuse my thoughts, this is just my opinion from my experience. I’m not generalizing Americans but there are lot of them that are racist. They thought that they are much higher than other race.
I can’t really disagree with your statement Karla except to say that it’s not only Americans. Racism is everywhere in the world; the recent row in soccer is proof of that.
Mitch,
I agree on several of your points while I also wonder what your thoughts are on “New Americans”, how that as a group that clearly faces prejudice they seem to be rising above it both in their education then in the work place?
Hi Kevin; good to see you here. My thought is “Give me your tired, your poor/Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free”; that’s what the Statue of Liberty says, and it didn’t discriminate based on anything in its language. I’m reminded of an old Redd Foxx joke of sorts where he stated that everyone finds someone to hate based on a difference. That’s true for the most part unfortunately, but if enough people recognize that the only difference between people is what they ultimately bring to the table as their strength or weakness as a person, we’ll be a much better country and world.
I hope that answered the question. 🙂
Could not agree with you more Mitch! My personal feeling is that folks (before and now) coming to the U.S. tend to have an unbiased perspective of the American Dream and that they tend to look beyond the hurdles of racism and inequality. I feel natural born citizens no matter what race, gender, etc… have somewhat lost our ability to dream and work together towards them.
We have a long way to go before we end the conversation of true diversity acceptance and inclusion but I’m hopeful when I look at my son’s generation and see that there is very little use of terms like “them” “those” “they” “us” when referring to groups of people.