Business Respect; Why Independent Consultants Don’t Get It
Posted by Mitch Mitchell on Mar 21, 2012
Someone asked me recently why I've been on a rant lately in regards to independent consulting and small businesses. He wondered if it merged well with what the blog has been about for the past 7 years, which is talking about leadership, diversity, customer service, motivation, health care, et al.
My response was that it all fits because it's all about business. I have given a lot of advice and some commentary over the years on all the things above. What I've noticed however is that there's two perceptions. One is that large companies can do it better, no matter what it is. The other is that consultants in general aren't good for any business, without any consideration that there are independent consultants and there are large companies that call some of their employees consultants, and there's a major difference.
Actually, there's a third perception, one that I'm addressing today, but I'll get to that in a minute. Let's say that you're a leader at your company and you need a service of some sort done. Do you always know who to go to? Probably not. If you have the authority you might go online to do a search, or you might call up someone you know to ask them who they might recommend.
Whether a leader goes with a large company with an established name because it's a name people have heard of, or does some diligence to see if there's someone closer and smaller with the skills to get the job done, it's a leadership decision. It can be a diversity decision if they exclude someone based on what they look like or their background. It could be a customer service decision if that person happens to be someone who could potentially use your services as well as you using theirs because, trust me, word gets out when it's discovered that you won't hire local people for projects yet are expecting the local populace to use them.
So yes, it all ties in together. I say that as I didn't even get an opportunity to bid on a local contract for services that I'm the only one in the area who provides those services. I say that as not even having an opportunity to lend a helping hand to another organization I had reached out to because I provide certain services.
Pretty much like this story I'm about to tell you that happened some years ago at a local SHRM meeting, a reason why I'm no longer a member of this group.
There was a special meeting that I was invited to, being a member at the time. The conversation was what types of services businesses felt they needed more information on and how they could get the information. Being an independent consultant, I went there knowing that this was a topic I could discuss well, as I'd also been in the real working world for many years.
The first two topics were something I know a lot about; leadership training and how to work on negotiating for insurance for employees. These were in two separate groups, and in each group, when no one else was saying anything, I started to try to offer some ideas, but was shut down by the moderator. Both times the moderator said they wanted to hear from people who were employed at companies right now.
What the hey? I was invited to come, I was a member of the organization, and they shut me down? Especially when, as it turned out, I was the only one in the room with the knowledge, the only one who could actually help?
Then came lunch, and I got some lunch and ended up sitting at a table with this guy I didn't know. He told me who he was and asked me who I was and what I did. I told him my name and said I was an independent consultant. He then said "You know, it's people like you that ruin this organization. I understand that we need people like you to help run this thing because the rest of us are doing real work, but it's too bad because your agenda is much different than ours."
I guess you can tell I wasn't all that happy a guy for the rest of the day. And it actually only lasted one more meeting for me before I left in the middle of it, disgusted, and knowing I was never going to another meeting, and was never renewing my membership, which is pretty steep. At that last meeting the topic was diversity, and they were discussing how they didn't know anyone in the area that provided diversity training; sigh...
I kept my mouth shut, and it was at that point that I decided I was leaving. I knew if I said anything that it wouldn't have been as nice as I normally speak. I was irked, insulted, depressed, and I'm sure I was feeling some other things as well.
This is a problem with some leaders, even minor ones. They get this impressions in their minds and there's nothing you can do to change them. And when they feel they have the right to talk to you as if you owe them something, that's when it's time to leave. I tell employees this type of thing all the time; when the people you work for show that they don't respect the work you do or you personally, it's time to look for something else. No one ever has to put up with disrespect.
Not even independent consultants. We won't always get the job, but that doesn't mean we don't deserve respect for what we know and what we do.
You are touching important issue, Mitch and unfortunately you are absolutely right. May be in most cases independent experts doesn’t get any respect, excepts few people that already do their job for many years and have become quite popular.
And it’s a shame Carl. I mean, I’ve been doing this 10 years, almost 11 by now, and one would think that longevity would give me more credence than it does.
There is one other thing which is coming to my mind. For your business I really can’t speak as I am not insider, but for mine, I think the reason is obvious, many “expert” are giving the business a bad name, so I think many companies are afraid hiring independent experts.
Carl, you’ve hit this one on the nail. There are a lot of bad consultants out there unfortunately, and they make it difficult for the rest of us.
Interesting topic. I never knew that consultants went through stuff like that or at least I never thought that their services were viewed in that manner. What’s funny is that companies outsource all the time and find value using independent consultants. How silly is that?
If you have the talent within the organization to get the job done than I can see where the need to outsource dies, but most times, they don’t have that department entirely covered. There is to me, always going to be a need for independent consultants because there will always be a certain expertise you just can’t always cover. This is no “one” person that knows it all no matter what companies want to think and then the need to outsource becomes attractive. It’s just how work gets done.
Consultants make my job easier and I would be dead in the water without their help. I don’t know everything and I am glad there are people out there with some particular expertise to help solve my problems.
Thanks Sonia. Yeah, it can be a tough road for an independent consultant. We don’t have the money for big budgets so we have to do other things to try to get noticed, and then we still get overlooked; just not right. I think Carl got it right though; there are so many bad consultants that don’t even try to get things done properly that it makes the entire industry look bad. I keep thinking that based on what I offer I should always be working. Not quite the case; luckily, I get to work enough so I at least can pay bills. But it’s time to step things up a lot.
Two things: What did the guy mean about “needing someone like you to keep the organization running?” I really don’t get that, unless he meant they need the dues you paid.
We don’t like to consider the negative emotions often driving numskulls to say the things they say: jealousy and fear. Jealous because they wish they had the b* (I mean, courage) to step up, put forth their expertise, get contracts, all under their own steam and on their own terms … irrespective of the mortgage, childcare and tuitions. And fear … see number one.
The key is in the semantics: “independent.”
Alas, diversity also plays a role, more often than we like to admit. (Not that YOU have a problem seeing that.)
I don’t have a contract to give you this week, Mitch, but you DO get my respect. 🙂
Vernessa, what he was getting at is that these days in many organizations independent consultants or small businesses often have half of, if not most of, the leadership positions in them, since it’s harder in this economy for actual employees to be allowed to leave to go to a meeting where they’re not learning anything specifically related to their job. I see it in the organizations I’m a part of now; it’s strange, but true.
You know, on the other end everyone has their own agenda and their own qualms about stuff, as well as just having to deal with the work and issues that constantly creep up. The thing is, sometimes everyone needs help, even if it’s just for a couple of hours to have someone else look at your situation and offer a possible solution. Are there bad consultants out there; absolutely. But most of them aren’t independent; we just can’t afford to be.